Choose your online store:  EU or  US  Canada  Australia
Point Grey Knowledge Base
Search for...
Search
        |     
Exclude unwanted words:
Browse KB Articles
Go Back Printable Version Email This Article Bookmark This Article

Key differences between rolling shutter and frame (global) shutter.

KB Number: 10028
Last Revision Date: 5/16/2014 10:31:01 AM
Created Date: 2/28/2014 4:01:12 PM

This article describes the differences between the rolling shutter used in CMOS sensors and the global (a.k.a. frame) shutter used in CCD sensors. 

Some types of CCD image sensors, such as the interline CCDs used by most PGR Imaging Products, provide an electronic shutter mechanism known as a global (or frame) shutter. In imagers that use a global shutter, the entire imager is reset before integration to remove any residual signal in the sensor wells. The wells (pixels) then accumulate charge for some period of time, with the light collection starting and ending at exactly the same time for all pixels. At the end of the integration period (time during which light is collected), all charges are simultaneously transferred to light shielded areas of the sensor. The light shield prevents further accumulation of charge during the readout process. The charges are then shifted out of the light shielded areas of the sensor and read out.

This means that with a global shutter sensor, the scene will be "frozen" in time, provided that the integration time is short enough i.e. there is no motion blur. An example of an image taken using a global shutter is below.

The rolling shutter in a CMOS image sensor works differently, in that the photodiodes (pixels) do not collect light at the same time. All pixels in one row of the imager collect light during exactly the same period of time, but the time light collection starts and ends is slightly different for each row. The top row of the imager is the first one to start collecting the light and is the first one to finish collecting. The start and end of the light collection for each following row is slightly delayed. The total light collection time for each row is exactly the same, and the delay between rows is constant.

The time delay between a row being reset and a row being read is the integration time. By varying the amount of time between when the reset sweeps past a row and when the readout of the row takes place, the integration time can be controlled.

Since the integration process moves through the image over some length of time, users should keep in mind the following issues when working with rolling shutter sensors:

Motion Blur

Some motion blur may become apparent. An example of an image taken using a rolling shutter is below.

Rolling Shutter
Global (Frame) Shutter

 

Strobe Light Capture

Rolling shutter integration is not well-suited for capturing short-pulse light sources such as strobe light. Unless the light source remains on for the duration of exposure, there is no guarantee that adjusting shutter time or strobe duration will result in adequate capture of the light source. Point Grey recommends against using rolling shutter sensors for short-pulse light applications.

Frame Rate When Triggering

When image capture on a rolling shutter camera is triggered by an external source, achievable frame rate is half the rate achievable in free-running mode, regardless of the rate that is specified. This difference is caused by a change in the way rolling shutter cameras operate between free-running and trigger modes. In free-running mode, integration can occur as quickly as the camera's pixel clock allows, because by the time the bottom row of the image sensor has integrated, the top row is already read out, and is free to integrate the next image without delay. In trigger mode, however, rolling shutter cameras begin read-out only after the entire image is integrated. The camera is not ready to receive another trigger until read-out is complete. Essentially, one frame is required for reset, and one frame for read-out. As a result, the frame rate achieved in trigger mode will be half the rate specified for free-running mode.

Switch Noise

The row-by-row process of light collection in a rolling shutter camera can also result in a switch noise effect, particularly at high gain settings. The image linked below shows this effect at maximum gain:

Switch Noise at Maximum Gain

Global Reset

For models with the global reset feature, rolling shutter distortion may be minimized by capturing images in Trigger_Mode 0, Trigger_Mode_1, or Trigger_Mode 15 (only when number of acquired images = 1). In these modes, exposure is controlled by the global reset feature of the sensor. In global reset mode, all of the pixels on the sensor begin collecting charge simultaneously, rather than row by row. The end of integration, however, is still delayed on the sensor row by row from top to bottom as readout takes place. One result of this behavior is a partial reduction in motion blur and other effects typical of rolling shutters. Another less desirable effect may be a gradual increase in brightness from  top to bottom of an image.

Unlike standard rolling shutter behavior, using a strobe flash in global reset mode may further reduce image distortion, and in dark conditions may even eliminate it.

 

Go Back Printable Version Email This Article Bookmark This Article